NAT vs. SAN: Why Do We Isolate Them?
Hola!
Today I wanted to put in orden my thought about the differences between NAT (Network Address Translation) and SAN (Storage Area Network) for a practical set up or job interview. I eventually started wondering: Why is it common practice to isolate them?
I recalled my studies from CompTIA Network+, and with a bit of patience and curiosity, I drafted this short entry on the topic.
There are two primary reasons for isolating NAT and SAN networks:
- Optimal Performance
- Enhanced Security
Optimization Focus
When optimization is the goal, the focus typically includes:
- Avoiding Bottlenecks
- High-Speed Protocols
- Efficient Routing
What Are High-Speed Protocols?
High-speed protocols are communication methods specifically designed to handle large volumes of data at very fast rates, minimizing latency and maximizing throughput—especially critical in environments like data centers and enterprise networks.
Example:
One common high-speed protocol is Fibre Channel, which is widely used in SAN environments. It supports extremely high data transfer rates (e.g., 16 Gbps or more), making it ideal for transferring large files such as medical imaging data or database transactions.
Security Focus
When isolating SANs for security purposes, the main concerns are:
- Reduced Attack Surface
- Contained Threats
Additional Management Benefits
Beyond performance and security, there are operational advantages that make isolation even more appealing:
- Simplified Backups
- Independent Infrastructure
Real-World Example: Healthcare IT Scenario
Imagine you're the IT administrator for a growing healthcare clinic. The clinic is implementing a new Electronic Health Record (EHR) system that will run on virtual servers. This system will store and retrieve thousands of large patient files, including high-resolution medical images.
Based on a simple network diagram I drafted, we can explore the following question:
Why would you propose a dedicated, high-bandwidth storage network (like a SAN) for the virtual servers, instead of using storage over the clinic's main network?
Performance Reasons
- It’s essential to guarantee high performance, especially for EHR systems handling large medical image files.
- It helps prevent network congestion, particularly during transfers of large radiology images.
- It ensures instant access to data, with high-speed connections enabling real-time image transfers and quick retrieval of patient records—which modern healthcare systems demand.
Security Reasons
- Reducing the Attack Surface: Patient records are highly sensitive and must comply with regulations like HIPAA.
- Containing Threats: A separate physical or logical network for storage creates a secure zone, reducing the risk of unauthorized access or malware spread.
Conclusion
By isolating SANs from general-purpose NAT-based networks, you gain:
- Better Performance
- Higher Reliability
- Stronger Security
All of which are essential in today’s complex and data-driven IT environments—especially in industries like healthcare, where speed, uptime, and privacy are non-negotiable.
More info:
- https://www.cdw.com/content/cdw/en/articles/datacenter/nas-vs-san.html
- https://www.tycoonstory.com/why-should-your-business-consider-a-storage-area-network-san/
- https://www.backblaze.com/blog/whats-the-diff-nas-vs-san/
- https://www.masterdc.com/blog/nas-san-and-das-how-to-distinguish-data-storages/
- https://www.datastorageconnection.com/doc/the-buzz-about-storage-area-networking-san-0001
Discuss this post: Bluesky
